Hilleberg's inner tent material

I have seen postings recently where backpackers are complaining about Hilleberg's inner tent material, that it isn't breathable enough, that it should be made of screen mesh throughout.

Listen, folks, Hilleberg knows what they are doing and they have a VERY valid reason for how their inner tents are designed.  Bear in mind-------- these are four season tents....they are made to withstand driving snow and rain.  If the inner tent was pure mesh or mosquito netting, rest assured that the occupants would be getting wet, because there would bound to be seepage through the bottom of the outer tent.  So they know that this happens, and while the inner tent fabric is very breathable, it inhibits water from penetrating the fabric.  BUT, the doors of the inner tent DO have a screen as well as a zip up piece of fabric to protect the occupants when all heck breaks loose.

Hilleberg tests all of their models and I have found that time and again there is a good reason why they do what they do.